Has the Illegal Alien Population Dropped Below 11 Million?

human-334110_960_720In 2015, the Center for Migration Studies (CMS) published a report by Robert Warren on the size of the illegal alien population was aimed at belying GOP presidential candidate Donald Trump’s speculation that the population could be as high as 34 million. Warren has now taken his estimates a step further and has reported that the size of the illegal alien population has fallen below 11 million persons.

Warren is a recognized expert in estimating the size of the illegal alien population, but the process he uses, and that of other demographers such as those at the Migration Policy Institute and the Pew Hispanic Center are, nevertheless, based on some shaky assumptions. The most important assumption is that the data collected by the government in the annual Current Population Survey (CPS) includes a representative sample of illegal aliens. Warren’s estimates are based on a residual method of eliminating aliens identified in the CPS who are legally present thereby identifying the remainder as illegal residents.

The difficulty with this methodology is the necessary assumption that illegal aliens are less likely to be included in the CPS sample as are legal alien residents. For obvious reasons, illegal aliens who are often described as ‘living in the shadows’ are likely to avoid becoming included in any governmental survey activity. Warren assumes that for recently arrived illegal aliens this omission is about 12 percent and that rate dwindles with the length of illegal residence dropping to two percent for the longest residents. If, instead the underrepresentation of illegal aliens in the CPS sample is double or ten times those estimates, then the size of the estimated illegal alien population is of a much larger magnitude.

The one element of Warren’s estimates that makes some sense is that by applying the same methodology from year to year the difference between the annual findings represents the amount of change in the illegal alien population. This reasonable assumption, however, becomes shakier if the inclusion of illegal aliens in the CPS sample is small. That smallness would allow small changes in the trend in illegal immigration from one country or region to skew the estimate.

The above analysis is not to say that Warren is necessarily wrong. Border apprehension data indicate that illegal entry by Mexicans – which was the major source of illegal immigration – has probably dropped considerably. But, it should be clear that his estimates should be received with the recognition that they are only as good as the data source, and that is questionable.

avatar About Jack Martin

Jack, who joined FAIR in 1995, is a retired U.S. diplomat with consular experience. He has testified before the U.S. Congress, U.S. Civil Rights Commission, and U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform and has authored studies of immigration issues. His national and international print, TV, and talk radio experience is extensive (including in Spanish).

Comments

  1. avatar No Change says:

    Jack this 11 million are probably if not more independent than 50% of The People……really….no help and whatsoever and being abused…they still make it……..many like you age…still making it…….the main issue here is the outsourced of the jobs and companies as a whole with the cubans somalis refugees and Welfare………which most ARE not from the 11 million but us and the legal residents……

    • avatar No Change says:

      that is the sad truth we are all being lied to by Congress and the new puppets’ presidential candidates……

  2. Trump Did Business in Vegas Where IAs Run Rabid

    He knows they’re low balling the number of IAs.